s Beyond Loss Prevention: CAP Index on Retail Crime Uncovered | CAP Index
How much of an organization’s security strategy is driven by objective data, and how much is influenced by experience, instinct, or established practices?

It’s an important consideration, particularly for retailers managing hundreds or thousands of locations, each with its own unique risk profile.

CAP Index’s Walter Palmer, Senior Advisor, and Dr. Casey Harris, VP of Risk Modeling, recently joined Emmeline Taylor on the Retail Crime Uncovered podcast to discuss how organizations approach crime risk modeling and the decisions it helps inform.

Their conversation explored several important aspects of risk modeling, from data quality and model development to the challenges of translating risk intelligence into meaningful action. Two especially important ideas emerged: the value of applying crime risk intelligence beyond loss prevention and the importance of using objective data to evaluate established security practices.

 

1. The Value of Crime Risk Intelligence Beyond Loss Prevention

When organizations consider the applications of crime risk modeling, security decisions are often the primary focus. Where should guards be deployed? Which locations require additional surveillance? How should limited security resources be allocated?

These are important to consider, but they represent only part of what risk intelligence can help inform.

As Walter explained, one of the most significant limitations of crime risk modeling occurs when valuable information remains within loss prevention or asset protection departments rather than being incorporated into broader organizational decision-making.

Beyond traditional security applications, location-specific crime risk intelligence can be used to determine:

  • Store operating hours: Evaluating how local conditions and crime exposure may influence operating decisions.
  • Staffing and management responsibilities: Considering differences in location-specific risk when assigning personnel and oversight responsibilities.
  • Resource allocation: Identifying where additional attention or investment may be warranted across a portfolio.
  • Operational planning: Incorporating crime risk considerations into broader organizational strategies and decisions.

Walter illustrated this concept with an example of a UK retailer that incorporates location-specific risk when determining how many stores an asset protection manager should oversee. For example, in Yorkshire, where the crime risk profile is lower, a manager might be responsible for 15 stores. But in East London, which has a significantly different risk profile, a manager might oversee only four locations.

The difference reflects the different levels of complexity associated with managing locations in vastly different environments. Stores facing greater security challenges typically require more attention and resources, making an equal distribution of locations less practical.

As Walter explained: “When you start making not only asset protection or security decisions based off the data, but also organizational and operational decisions, that’s where crime risk profiles become really powerful.”

This example demonstrates how crime risk intelligence can help organizations make decisions that extend beyond traditional security investments. By incorporating location-specific risk into broader business planning, organizations can develop a more complete understanding of operational demands and allocate resources accordingly.

2. Balancing Professional Experience With Objective Risk Data

Security decisions are shaped by professional experience, historical practices, and perceptions of risk. While valuable, these perspectives can also influence how organizations evaluate the necessity and effectiveness of existing security measures.

Consider a store manager who strongly believes their location requires a security guard. Previous incidents or employee concerns may reinforce that perception even when a broader analysis suggests the location faces relatively low risk compared to others in the portfolio. This situation creates a challenge: how should organizations respond when perceived risk and modeled risk do not align?

During the podcast, Walter and Casey discussed how personal experiences and established practices can influence security resource allocation, particularly when employees have developed a strong attachment to certain protective measures.

Casey explained that risk modeling provides a more consistent and objective framework for evaluating these decisions: “That’s one of the roles of risk modeling: to disentangle anecdotal emotional decisions made in the past – many times for very good reasons –  and to focus on more objective, comparable decision-making within a larger portfolio.” For organizations managing large portfolios, this consistency is particularly valuable. A security measure considered essential at one location may not represent the most effective allocation of resources when evaluated alongside the needs of other locations.

However, Casey also emphasized that discrepancies between perceived and modeled risk should not automatically lead organizations to dismiss employee concerns. In some cases, a model may suggest that a location could reduce its security presence, only for further discussions to reveal that certain incidents have not been consistently reported. Lack of knowledge of these incidents can lead to the wrong security decision.

When employee perceptions and modeled risk differ, organizations have an opportunity to:

  • Examine reporting practices: Determine whether incidents are being consistently documented across locations.
  • Identify gaps in available data: Investigate whether missing information may be influencing modeled risk assessments.
  • Reevaluate existing security measures: Consider whether current resource allocations reflect actual conditions and organizational priorities.
  • Encourage cross-departmental communication: Bring together security teams, store management, and other stakeholders to develop a more complete understanding of risk.

Rather than viewing employee perceptions and objective risk data as competing perspectives, organizations can use both to better understand location-specific challenges. This approach recognizes the value of firsthand experience while establishing a more consistent, evidence-based foundation for security decisions.

Applying Risk Intelligence More Effectively

The discussion between Walter, Casey, and Emmeline highlights an important distinction between developing a crime risk model and effectively incorporating its findings into organizational decision-making.

While risk models provide a consistent framework for evaluating locations, their usefulness also depends on how organizations communicate and apply the information they produce.

Expanding risk intelligence beyond loss prevention can help organizations consider crime exposure in broader operational planning. Similarly, evaluating modeled risk alongside employee experiences can reveal opportunities to improve data quality, reassess existing practices, and better understand security needs.

Ultimately, these two ideas reinforce the importance of treating crime risk modeling as an ongoing process of evaluation and refinement. By combining objective data with operational knowledge, organizations can develop a more comprehensive understanding of risk and make more consistent, informed decisions across their locations.

Listen to the full episode of Retail Crime Uncovered to hear more from Walter Palmer and Dr. Casey Harris.

About Retail Crime Uncovered

Hosted by Professor Emmeline Taylor, Retail Crime Uncovered explores the latest research, trends, and challenges shaping the retail crime landscape. Through expert interviews and industry discussions, the podcast examines topics such as loss prevention, organized retail crime, emerging technologies, and data-driven security strategies, offering valuable insights for retail and security professionals.

 

Recent Posts

Same City, Different Risk: What Atlanta Reveals About Smarter Security Decisions
Same City, Different Risk: What Atlanta Reveals About Smarter Security Decisions
CAP Index's latest analysis of Atlanta crime trends reveals how differences in location, offense type, and timing ...
Crime Analytics and Healthcare Security: Casey T. Harris on The HealthSpark
Crime Analytics and Healthcare Security: Casey T. Harris on The HealthSpark
CAP Index’s Casey T. Harris, Ph.D., joins The HealthSpark to discuss how crime analytics can help healthcare ...
Our First GSX: Three Perspectives from the CAP Index Sales Team
Our First GSX: Three Perspectives from the CAP Index Sales Team
For CAP Index team members Kyle Andersen, Mitch Koch, and Kevin Kelly, GSX 2026 offered a chance to do exactly ...
No results found.